Whey vs. Casein: Which One is Better?
Whey vs. Casein: Which One is Better?
Casein protein vs. Whey protein: What protein to take, when, and why.
I’ve heard a lot from people regarding when and why they take whey or casein or simply get it from alternative protein sources. One I hear frequently is that bodybuilders eat cottage cheese or take casein before bed to prevent muscle breakdown while they sleep. The rationale is that casein is a “slow” protein whereas whey is a “fast” protein. But, is one source of protein better than the other? Is there a benefit from consuming whey post-workout and casein at other times? Let’s examine the facts.
First, the bad news: research can’t tell us the answer to every question. From the current body of literature, it isn’t possible to determine exactly how much protein each person needs after a workout and at specific times of the day (after all, people vary and so do their workouts and genetics) so they maximize their training while minimizing waste (in the form of money spent on food or protein supplements). But, we do know a lot about the amino acid content of various proteins and which ones increase muscle protein synthesis (which, over time, should result in strength and mass gains).
Both whey and casein are milk proteins and both are high in the protein digestibility corrected amino acid score (PDCAA is a measure of the digestibility of a protein and the amino acids necessary for an adult – a higher number is better). Additionally, both are high in total BCAAs (the ones that are especially important for boosting muscle growth and decreasing muscle breakdown). But, take a look at how these proteins stack up on PDCAA and one of the key BCAAs, leucine:
As you can see, whey is the highest in leucine. However, there are actually relatively few studies that compare casein and whey head-to-head. Here’s what we know: studies show that 20 grams of whey protein, taken immediately before or immediately after resistance training results in a significant increase in muscle protein synthesis. The same amount of casein, 20 grams, has also been shown to increase muscle protein synthesis.
Now, what about longer term? In a 10-week study, 13 recreational male bodybuilders ate their normal diet and also supplemented with whey or casein (1.5 grams per kg bodyweight). By all means, whey came out ahead. The group given whey showed greater gains in strength and lean body mass as well as increased fat loss compared to the casein group. Pretty convincing yes, even though it was a small study.
So what’s the bottom line on whey vs. casein post-workout and which is the better supplement for athletes? Given what we know now, whey is better than casein for stimulating muscle growth.
Knowing that what’s the point of casein and can taking it right before bed increase muscle growth when you sleep? Casein has a high PDCAA, it’s well digested, and has a great array of amino acids. Additionally, casein has a longer lasting effect (the amino acids don’t peak immediately but instead peak over a period of time) and according to one study, casein delivered a longer lasting anabolic response, which is why many athletes and bodybuilders opt to take it before bed. Does it work to decrease muscle protein breakdown while you sleep and do you “lose” muscle while sleeping anyway? Possibly, but in all likelihood that depends on the person’s overall protein intake, training program, and general health. However, if you need to gain weight and build muscle, it may make sense to take something like casein, or a food rich in casein like cottage cheese, before bed.
- Athletes and those who exercise need more protein than the average person. Although really, many people need more than the Recommended Dietary Allowances (but that’s a whole different topic!).
- Everyone needs protein throughout the day. Many studies show that it is beneficial to consume protein throughout the day (25-30 grams per meal for adults) vs. the typical American diet where we consume a tiny bit at breakfast, a little more at lunch and a lot at dinner.
- There is a window of opportunity after exercise of about 30 minutes. You must consume protein post-workout to maximize muscle protein synthesis and therefore benefit the most from your training. Think about it this way: it doesn’t make sense to do all that hard work in the gym and skimp on nutrition. If you do that you won’t get the physique and strength benefits you’re looking for. How much do you need post-workout? At least 20 grams of quality protein, high in BCAAs.
If you do nothing else, and have ignored the explanation of how whey protein differs from casein protein above, follow these 3 points and you’ll see an increase in strength and lean muscle gains.
Phillips S. Wheying the Evidence on Dairy in Sports. The ISSN’s 2008 annual conference.
Phillips et al 2008.
J Strength Cond Res. 2006;20(3):643-53.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2004;36(12):2073-81.
Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 2006;16(5):494-509.
Med Sci Sports Exerc 2004;36(12):2073-81.
Am J Physiol 273(1 Pt 1): E122-9.
Am J Clin Nutr 2007;86(2):373-81.
Am J Clin Nutr 2007;86(2):373-81.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1997;94(26):14930-5.
Looking for a great tasting whey protein options? 1R would recommend the following great tasting products:
- Gaspari IntraPro - This post workout protein shake that's loaded with BCAAs, L-Glutamine, and Taurine, will help you recover, and build lean
- Cytosport Whey Isolate – Naturally rich in glutamine, BCAA’s and other important nutrients, this protein supplement will help you build lean muscle mass when taken after training sessionsmuscle, faster after workouts
- Optimum Nutrition 2:1:1 Recovery - The carbs and protein will help you recover and build lean muscle faster after tough workouts
About the Author
Marie Spano is one of the country’s top sports nutritionists and a nutrition communications expert. She combines science with practical experience to help Olympic, professional and recreational athletes implement a nutrition game plan that will maximize their athletic performance. Marie also works with leading food, beverage and supplement companies on their PR and communications strategies. She has appeared on NBC, ABC, Fox and CBS affiliates on the east coast, written hundreds of magazine articles, trade publication articles, book chapters, e-zines and marketing materials. Ms. Spano holds an MS in Nutrition from the University of Georgia where she worked as a graduate assistant in the athletic department and a BS degree is in Exercise and Sports Science from UNC, Greensboro, NC where she ran Division 1 cross country.
- (1) May 2013
- (4) April 2013
- (1) March 2013
- (4) January 2013
- (11) December 2012
- (20) November 2012
- (20) October 2012
- (19) September 2012
- (22) August 2012
- (23) July 2012
- (20) June 2012
- (18) May 2012
- (19) April 2012
- (17) March 2012
- (10) February 2012
- (12) January 2012
- (15) December 2011
- (15) November 2011
- (15) October 2011
- (15) September 2011
- (17) August 2011
- (15) July 2011
- (14) June 2011
- (10) May 2011
- (7) April 2011
- (7) March 2011
- (6) February 2011
- (5) January 2011
- (5) December 2010
- (3) November 2010